I Tried So Many Lip Balms for Dry Lips. Only 3 Were Worth It

I buy most products myself. This post contains affiliate links. Full disclosure

Lips still dry and tight, no matter how often you reapply?

My #1 is the Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve. The Uriage Moisturizing Lipstick is my light, long-lasting pick. And the expensive L:A Bruket was too oily for me.

This post is for you if:

  • Your lips get dry from AC or heating all day
  • You don’t like sticky or heavy lip balms
  • You’re wondering if an expensive lip balm is worth it

If you’ve read any of my previous posts, you probably already know this about me.

My skin doesn’t do well with air conditioning. And neither do my lips.

At work, I sit under pretty strong AC for 8 to 9 hours a day. By the afternoon, my lips usually feel dry and tight, and I find myself reaching for lip balm over and over again.

So honestly, work is where I use lip products the most.

Today, I wanted to share three lip products I’ve been using and how I would rank them.

One of them is my favorite, one of them I will definitely repurchase, and the last one… well, I really wanted to love it. 🥲


What I Look for in a Lip Product

Before I get into the products, let me tell you what matters to me.

  • Not sticky. I have a really hard time with anything sticky. Not just lip products, anything.
  • Not too thick or heavy. I don’t like the stuffy feeling when a thick layer just sits on my lips.
  • Long-lasting. When you are under AC for 8 to 9 hours, you have to reapply a lot. So staying power is really important to me.

So basically, I want something light, not sticky, but still long-lasting.

That sounds simple, but it was harder to find than I thought.

Lip balms I've tried, including eos, ChapStick, Carmex, Fenty Skin, Uriage, Ole Henriksen and L:A Bruket
These are just the ones I still have. I’ve tried way more than this!

Lip balms that didn’t work for me

Carmex was one of them. It’s everywhere in the U.S., so I figured I’d give it a try.

But I didn’t really like it.

It felt like there was a coating sitting on top of my lips, which I found uncomfortable. And even though it felt heavy, the moisture didn’t seem to last very long.

EOS was another one I tried after hearing good things about it.

Unfortunately, I wasn’t too impressed with the staying power, and I didn’t particularly enjoy the texture either.

ChapStick was the same story. It sits heavy on top of my lips, but the moisture doesn’t last long. It felt really temporary.

You can find EOS, ChapStick, and Carmex anywhere. But honestly, I will not buy them unless they are the only option I have.

One more I tried is the Fenty Skin lip balm. This one is actually good! But it’s a little pricey for the size.

Anyway, here are the three products I wanted to talk about today.


#1. Ole Henriksen – Pout Preserve Hydrating Peptide Lip Treatment

Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve Peptide Lip Treatment
Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve · Check price on Amazon

If I had to pick only one, it’s this one. No question.

I already talked about it in my Holy Grail post, but I couldn’t leave it out of a lip post.

Funny thing is, this is not really my kind of texture.

As I said, I don’t like lip products that go on thick. Normally, I wouldn’t have even considered this one.

But about once a year, my lips get really, really dry. So dry that they crack all over. During one of those times, I was desperate, so I tried a thick formula for the first time. And this was the one I picked.

And surprisingly, even though it goes on thick, it doesn’t feel stuffy at all. Most of all, it fills my lips with moisture really, really well.

Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve lip treatment in Strawberry Sorbet
My Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve (Strawberry Sorbet)

It’s glossy when you put it on. As you can see in the photo, it has a slight color, but it’s not strong enough to actually color your bare lips.

So if you put it on over your lip makeup, it gives a nice glossy look on top.

And the scent. I love it SO much.

I was actually deciding between this one and the Summer Fridays lip balm, and the scent is the reason I picked this one. It also comes in several different scents, so you can choose the one you like.


#2. Uriage – Moisturizing Lipstick

Uriage Moisturizing Lipstick held in hand
My Uriage Moisturizing Lipstick · Check price on Amazon

This one was recommended to me by a friend.

Her lips get dry just like mine, and she has the same standards as me when it comes to picking lip products. So when she recommended it, I trusted her right away.

Uriage is not a U.S. brand, so Amazon was the fastest place I could get it.

First of all, it goes on very light. There is almost no stuffy feeling.

When you apply it, it feels soft and moisturizing.

And the staying power is really good. Light AND long-lasting. That’s exactly what I was looking for.

Uriage Moisturizing Lipstick opened, showing the clear balm
A simple, clear balm

I mostly use this one before bed.

Because it’s light but lasts long, I put on a lot of it before I go to sleep, and my lips feel so moisturized the next morning.

The scent is a little bit like cherry… maybe a mix of cherry and vanilla? But it’s very subtle, not pungent at all. You can use it without worrying about the scent.

After you put it on, your lips look a little shiny, but not super glossy. I would say it’s about the same shine as EOS or Burt’s Bees.

Honestly, I don’t have anything bad to say about this one! The price is not bad at all either.

I will definitely repurchase it.


#3. L:A Bruket – No 017 Lip Balm

L:A Bruket No 017 Lip Balm held in hand
My L:A Bruket No 017 Lip Balm · Check price on Amazon

I am going to be honest here. I had really high expectations for this one.

Some people call it “the Hermès of lip balms.” And it’s about 3 to 4 times more expensive than other lip balms.

I did a lot of research and read so many reviews before deciding to buy it. After thinking about it for a long time, I finally got it on Amazon when it was on sale. (Like Uriage, it’s not a U.S. brand, so Amazon was the fastest option for me.)

But… I was really disappointed. 😢

It was too oily for me.

Some people say they love it because it feels light. But for me, the oily, greasy feeling on my lips was just too much. I kept wiping it off.

Personally, it’s not a feeling I enjoy.

Top view of the wide L:A Bruket No 017 lip balm stick
It’s about the size of a glue stick.

To be fair, there are some good things about it.

The scent is a light almond scent. It’s very subtle, so it’s easy to use.

And the size is a huge plus. It’s about the size of a glue stick, so I think it will last a really long time.

If you don’t like the heavy feeling that most lip balms have, you might actually like this one.

But for me, I don’t think I will buy it again.


My Ranking

  1. Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve – Thick but not stuffy, really hydrating, and the scent is amazing.
  2. Uriage Moisturizing Lipstick – Light, long-lasting, and great before bed. Will repurchase!
  3. L:A Bruket No 017 – Too oily for me, but could work if you hate heavy lip balms.

Want to Read More?

If you also struggle with dryness, you might find these posts helpful:

💧 Hydrating vs. Moisturizing: Which One Does Dry Skin Need?
💧 Best Moisturizers for Dry Skin: My Morning and Night Picks
💧 Why My Skin Got So Dry After Moving From Korea to the U.S.

💧 11 Hand Creams I Tried for Dry Hands, Honestly Rated Out of 10


Final Thoughts

I learned that an expensive lip balm is not always the best lip balm.

Just like skincare, it really depends on what your lips need and what kind of texture you like.

For me, it’s all about light, not sticky, and long-lasting.

If you have a favorite lip balm for dry lips, please let me know! I’m always looking for the next one. ✨

Thank you for reading my post today! Hope you found something helpful 🙂

Sincerely,

Hazel 🙂

Disclosure: I buy most products myself. Some were gifts from friends or family, and I’ll always tell you when. No brand has ever paid me or sent me anything to review. Some links in this post are affiliate links, so if you buy through them I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what I recommend. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Responses

  1. VT Reedle Shot 100 vs 300: My Honest Review After a Year – Glow With Hazel Avatar

    […] If you also struggle with dry skin, you might find these posts helpful:💧 My Korean Skincare Routine for Dry Skin (Cleanser to Serum)💧 5 Skincare Products I Keep Repurchasing for Dry Skin💧 Lip Balms That Actually Work for My Dry Lips […]

    Like

  2. Why I Skip Fragrance on My Face (It’s Not Because of a Reaction) – Glow With Hazel Avatar

    […] And with lip balm, I don’t even think about it. I actually love the scent of my Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve. (I talked about it in my lip balm post.) […]

    Like

  3. 7 Hand Creams I Tried for Dry Hands at the Office (Honest Ranking) – Glow With Hazel Avatar

    […] 💧 I Tried So Many Lip Balms for Dry Lips. Only 3 Were Worth It💧 Red, Bumpy Skin Out of Nowhere? How I Calm a Damaged Skin Barrier💧 Why I Skip Fragrance on My Face […]

    Like

  4. 5 More Products I Keep Rebuying (Part 2) – Glow With Hazel Avatar

    […] It’s not expensive either. It came in at #2 in my lip balm post. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply